| Jamie Dupree |
Sotomayor On Trial
As the Senate starts to get ready for confirmation hearings on President Obama's choice for the U.S. Supreme Court, the best part is how much material is already available for review and being used by both sides.
There's the now infamous remarks that Judge Sonia Sotomayor made - and that were caught on videotape - where she talks about "making policy" on the appellate court level.
"All of the legal defense funds out there, they're looking for people with Court of Appeals experience. Because it is, Court of Appeals is where policy is made. And I know, and I know this is on tape and I should never say that, because we don't make law."
Sotomayor laughs at the end of that. To supporters, it's a knowing laugh which is not sinister. To her critics, it's rampant evidence of the worst kind of judicial activism.
She is certain to be asked about that at her confirmation hearings. One would assume that she will have a stock answer ready to go, one which she will repeat and repeat.
Another issue that seems likely to be brought up is a statement she made in a speech back in 2001 about how the experiences of judges should play in their work.
"I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn't lived that life," Sotomayor said.
Critics seized on this even before Sotomayor was nominated, charging that if a white man made the above statement about Hispanics, that person would be drummed out immediately and ripped as racist.
For a second straight day, that was a subject at the White House briefing, as reporters pestered spokesman Robert Gibbs over and over on the quote.
Look for that statement to get a full review in confirmation hearings - and even in one-on-one meetings with Senators.
Those two items have already sparked a lot of comments on the internet, so you can read an awful lot more about them with a couple clicks of the mouse.
Along with the upcoming decision on the New Haven, Connecticut firefighter promotion case that went before Sotomayor, I would expect - right now at least - that those three items will form the basis for criticism of her nomination.
Nothing is a given in these nomination fights. We'll see whether any of these statements, along with the firefighter case - and other opinions out there - cause any Democrats to get wobbly in the knees.
And nothing will matter if Sotomayor mishandles questions in her confirmation hearings.
That is unlikely. But you never know. Robert Bork didn't listen to his handlers.
They play these games for a reason.
You can also follow Jamie Dupree on both Twitter and on Facebook.
What others are saying
- Sotomayor On TrialOf the 14 cases she's ruled on that have gone on to the Supreme Court, 12 have been ruled on and 2 are still awaiting decisions.
Had she been on the SC instead of Souter - the one she's to replace - and decided in the same manner as she did on the Appeals Court Bench, the outcomes of all 12 cases would have been the same, albeit in a few cases the margins would have changed.
Souter was supposed to be more conservative than he turned out to be. Despite her apparent racism and sexism, there's reason to hope that Sotomayor may wind up more conservative than she's supposed to be. She doesn't represent a huge shift to the Left on the court. And should she be turned down, the next nominee could easily be worse. - sotomayorAnybody who has had 80% of their decisions overturned is far from qualified.
- ehWhile it is disappointing that she doesn't believe that I can live a full, rich life simply because I don't have her background, she is really mostly correct (though not a great choice of words) in her description of the Court of Appeals. Legal precedents are large influences in future decisions, and the Court of Appeals issues many more rulings than SCOTUS.
I've heard the appeal overturns argument bandied about a fair bit of late, but I've yet to see the actual statistics of cases judged, cases appealed and cases overturned. Can someone back this up? - SotomayorShe will not make a "good" Supreme Court justice. Her remarks are racist, she seems to have chip on her shoulder, she carries a grudge, her decisions are reversed more than half the time on appeal as she ignores statutory law, and she is yet another example of the double-standard so blantantly practiced by the left. Any SCOTUS nominee by an R President who had made these same remarks would be destroyed, personally and professionally, by the intolerant left.
- Sotomayor pending confirmation hearingI've listened to the full context of the two 'comments of concern' and determined there is nothing there. To also look at one decision many may not agree with and not take into consideration almost 20 years of court decisions is not how you evaluate her overall abilities.
I believe she will make a good Supreme Court justice based on her background.
WSB 24-Hour Weather Center
Get the 5-day Forecast .
Atlanta weather
Mostly Cloudy48°F
5-day forecast | Hurricane Guide
Marketplace
"How to Build Your Financial Future" Online Seminar sponsored by Associated Credit Union. Details
Shop for cars, find a dealer, and get the latest automotive news in our Local Car Buying Guide powered by AutoTrader.com
From fast food to fine dining, find it all in our Local Business Directory .
Stay ahead of the storm. Find evacuation routes, safety tips and more in the Hurricane Guide.
Read the AJC and stay on top of everything in Atlanta! Get delivery for less than $2 a week!
Join Channel 2 Action News anchors John Pruitt and Monica Pearson at 5, 6, and 11pm.










