| Jamie Dupree |
New Senate Health Bill
That big thud you heard last night was not the weekly newspaper slamming into the screen door on the front porch, but rather that was the latest health care bill from Senate Democrats, tipping the scales at 2,047 pages in all.
The basics of the bill are much like those we have seen before in the House and Senate, as it would do away with pre-existing condition insurance exclusions, guarantee the renewal of health coverage, prohibit discriminatory insurance rates and more.
But there are some key differences that emerged as I made my way through the bill last night, especially in how the bill would raise money to pay for these health reforms.
First, Senator Harry Reid's bill would raise the Medicare tax on people making more than $200,000 per year, and couples making more than $250,000. That would bring in almost $54 billion over ten years.
So much for that Presidential pledge not to raise taxes on people making more than $250k, eh?
The tax on high value, "Cadillac" insurance plans would be 40% under this bill.
The plan would also limit "Flexible spending accounts" that some workers use to shield up to $3,000 in income each year, by putting pre-tax dollars into health accounts. For some, that amount would be limited to $2,500.
This bill would even levy a 5% tax on elective cosmetic surgery procedures. So, if you are thinking about a nose job or a face lift, you might want to get cracking on that plan to save yourself some dough.
One interesting change in the bill is that the public option is no more in this Senate legislation, as it has been renamed the "Community Health Insurance Option".
A preliminary estimate from the Congressional Budget Office pegs the cost at $848 billion over ten years, but a lot of other things could still get added.
Sen. Reid now hopes to at least get a vote on the motion to proceed to the bill, so that after Thanksgiving, the debate will be all about the health care bill, and not parliamentary motions.
It could keep the Senate in session this week and into Thanksgiving week.
Interested in reading through the bill itself? You can download it at http://is.gd/4YoJC
Stay tuned.
What others are saying
- Harry S. Truman 1945None of this is really new. The American people are the most insurance-minded people in the world. They will not be frightened off from health insurance because some people have misnamed it "socialized medicine".
I repeat--what I am recommending is not socialized medicine.
Socialized medicine means that all doctors work as employees of government. The American people want no such system. No such system is here proposed.
Under the plan I suggest, our people would continue to get medical and hospital services just as they do now--on the basis of their own voluntary decisions and choices. Our doctors and hospitals would continue to deal with disease with the same professional freedom as now. There would, however, be this all-important difference: whether or not patients get the services they need would not depend on how much they can afford to pay at the time.
I am in favor of the broadest possible coverage for this insurance system. I believe that all persons who work for a living and their dependents should be covered under such insurance plan. This would include wage and salary earners, those in business for themselves, professional persons, farmers, agricultural labor, domestic employees, government employees and employees of non-profit institutions and their families.
In addition, needy persons and other groups should be covered through appropriate premiums paid for them by public agencies. Increased Federal funds should also be made available by the Congress under the public assistance programs to reimburse the States for part of such premiums, as well as for direct expenditures made by the States in paying for medical services provided by doctors, hospitals and other agencies to needy persons.
We are a rich nation and can afford many things. But ill health that can be prevented or cured is one thing we cannot afford.
What I have discussed heretofore has been a program for improving and spreading the health services and facilities of the Nation, and providing an efficient and less burdensome system of paying for them. But no matter what we do, sickness will of course come to many. Sickness brings with it loss of wages.
Therefore, as a fifth element of a comprehensive health program, the workers of the Nation and their families should be protected against loss of earnings because of illness. A comprehensive health program must include the payment of benefits to replace at least part of the earnings that are lost during the period of sickness and long-term disability. This protection can be readily and conveniently provided through expansion of our present social insurance system, with appropriate adjustment of premiums. - Congress Participating?I believe these yayhoos have voted (several times already), to exclude themselves from having to participate in their government healthcare plan.
- Health Care?REALLY!? They are not interested in our health, let alone our health CARE. They don't even care how much it will cost. It's not THEIR money they are spending. They have no common sense nor do they want to listen to anyone who HAS common sense. Wouldn't it make more sense to fix Medicare and Medicaid first? If they just fixed the abuse alone in both those GOVERNMENT-RUN-HEALTH-CARE entities they would have the money for the other TRUE reforms that are needed. What they SAY is not to be trusted because it's NOT about HEALTH CARE.
- Jamie, at one time Congress pledged they would be under whatever health plan passes. Are they still saying that?
- FSAsEliminating FSAs is also a tax on those who make less than $250K a year. Many of my friends who make significantly less than $200K utilize the FSA to reduce their taxable income and to pay for expected medical expenses with pre-tax dollars. With the Senate plan, my co-workers will now be paying taxes before taking care of their own medical expenses.
As I told some folks in Charlottesville, VA gathering signatures to support "health care reform," "Why don't the Democrats quit lying and just try to pass single payer health care. I'd respect them more than doing it piecemeal and then acting surprised when the entire health care industry is destroyed and we're forced into a single payer system. - Health Bill - require congressional use?Hey Jamie:
Does this Senate bill or the House give those elected officials to be exempt from following these and keep separate plan? What is good for the goose is good for the gander.... force them to use the same plan that the uninsured would get and pay the same fines etc... - Healthcare bbillIf you take the actual text of the House's bill and convert it to what you would normally write on a sheet of paper, it actually takes up only about 322 pages. These bills are printed using triple spacing, extra large font and use only about 1/4 of the actual space on a piece of paper. So, based on this, I would think that it should not be hard to read the entire thing in a few hours. I did it.
- 890 billion / 36 million = $24,722.22 per person. That would buy a Cadillac plan wouldn't it? Why not give vouchers to the uninsured instead for 1/2 the cost?
- I heard they forgot to pay the doctorsSomeone might confirm that they left out paying the doctors in the Senate bill.
- Bob's mathBob,
Try your math again, that is 89,000,000,000/36,000,000=$2,472.22 per person per year - Harry ReidI hope the good people of Nevada will do us all a huge favor next year ans send Harry Reid packing. This goon is like a cancer on the whole country.
- $894 billion = $89 billion per year. Health care reform will . . . eventually . . . cover 36 million who are currently uninsured. That's $2 million per uninsured per year.
This isn't working for me. - Amazing!That our elected representatives are even considering this stupendously flawed legislation is unbelievable.
That our elected representatives present this bill without realizing how ridiculous it is is farcical.
That a large percentage of our population sees this as a legitimate course of action is sad. Truly sad. - House CleaningHouse cleaning is right! They don't seem too concerned about what the people they represent want. Quite the opposite in some cases...
- Boondoggle from FloridaYet another bloated boondoggle by our elected officials. Funny, when the majority of Anericans don't want this thing, they push ahead.
Time for major housecleaning I say!
advertisement
advertisement
Marketplace
Knowing Your Heart Disease Risk. Smart. Piedmont Heart Institute. Brilliant. Learn more
advertisement
Get the latest Medical Minute report presented by Atlanta Health Experts.
Get information about Prostate Cancer and its Treatments. View the online seminar.
Shop for cars, find a dealer, and get the latest automotive news in our Local Car Buying Guide powered by AutoTrader.com
From fast food to fine dining, find it all in our Local Business Directory .News/Talk 750 WSB wants to make sure you can access our website anytime you want from any device. Click here to find out how.
Help do your part to save water, reduce air pollution & greenhouse emissions. Go Green!
Your online connection to the Georgia Bulldogs Radio Network team!
Read the AJC and stay on top of everything in Atlanta! Get delivery for less than $2 a week!
Join Channel 2 Action News anchors John Pruitt and Monica Pearson at 5, 6, and 11pm.










